This is my favorite. Nice simple decor, great location next door to the fishermen bringing in the catch and consistently wonderful food.
Grilled whitefish. Grilled lake trout with a side of trout chowder. The general catches are lake trout, whitefish and herring (cisco). Because the lake is so cold and clear, it doesn't produce huge numbers of fish, but what it does are wonderful. Just a quick word about the Lake Superior Oatmeal Stout. The best I've ever tasted. Worth building a meal around.